Trader Joe’s is renowned for offering some of the best grocery store cheeses that are both delicious and affordable. Perfect for elevating a charcuterie board or a simple weekday meal, these cheeses are a must-have for any occasion.
After sampling numerous cheeses, here are some of our editors’ top picks, complete with recommendations for accompaniments to enhance your culinary experience.
Manchego at $13.99 per pound (usually in smaller blocks) is a favorite among our team, including senior fact-checker Maya Kukes. It’s a delightful blend of sharp, salty, and nutty, consistently more affordable at Trader Joe’s than other stores. Senior food editor Sam Leffler loves its nutty, buttery flavor, ideal for pairing with cured meats and perfect for cheese lovers.
Sam Leffler also praises the Italian Truffle Cheese for its right balance of truffle flavor, excellent with crackers and honey. Leftover cheese can enhance scrambled eggs.
Features editor Melissa Matthews adores the Baked Lemon Ricotta, likening it to cheesecake, especially when paired with graham crackers and fresh berries.
The Cheddar Cheese with Caramelized Onions is a versatile personal favorite, offering a unique twist to grilled sandwiches and puff pastries. It’s a picnic staple, with friends frequently inquiring about its origin.
For goat cheese fans, the Chèvre With Honey, a previous Trader Joe’s crew member favorite, balances tangy goat cheese with sweet honey, making it perfect for spreads or charcuterie.
Senior social media editor Sam Saunion enjoys the Cranberry Chèvre Goat Cheese, paired with Ritz crackers for a sweet and salty treat. Creative director Phoebe Flynn Rich recommends the seasonal Blueberry Vanilla Chèvre in spring.
The Double Cream Brie is another stand-out—rich, smooth, and perfect melted on sandwiches or wraps. Benjamin DeMarais favors wrapping it in puff pastry with jam for a delectable bite.
Editorial director Jennifer Davidson cherishes the Creamy Toscano Cheese Soaked in Syrah, praising its creamy, nutty blend of Parmesan and aged cheddar, perfect for pasta or cheese boards.
These chosen cheeses from Trader Joe’s are sure to be a hit at your next gathering or meal.
